What small claims court is

Last updated

A plain-English explanation of small claims court in the United States, including the different court names states use and what a hearing is for.

This is general information, not legal advice. Court rules differ, and a clerk can explain procedure without telling you whether you will win.

Small claims court is a simplified way to ask a judge for money. California's courts describe it as an easier way to take someone to court when you believe the other side owes you money. Massachusetts calls its session an informal and inexpensive forum. Maryland says the rules of evidence and procedure are simplified so a person can present a case without a lawyer, while still allowing a lawyer if you want one. The hearing is still a real court hearing. The judge, or in Massachusetts often a clerk-magistrate, listens to both sides, looks at the papers, and decides.

The name on the door is not the same in every state. Some states use the words "small claims" for a division inside a familiar trial court. Texas uses justice court. Delaware's courts chart smaller money and property claims in the Justice of the Peace Court, not in a court with "small claims" in the title. Georgia's Judicial Council describes magistrate court as the county court that hears smaller civil claims, and it notes that older small claims courts were folded into magistrate courts. Minnesota's statute calls the court conciliation court. West Virginia's civil limit for these cases sits in magistrate court. If a guide or a website insists every state has a courthouse named Small Claims Court, it is describing a nickname, not the sign on the building.

What these courts share is a dollar line and a shorter procedure. The line is set by a statute, a court rule, or an official court page, and it is different in each state. Interest and court costs are often left out of the line. Attorney fees sometimes count and sometimes do not. A claim that fits the line can be started with a short statement instead of a long formal complaint. The other person must still be served. A hearing date follows. There is often no jury. New Hampshire's statute is an exception worth knowing: when the claim exceeds $1,500, a defendant can ask for a jury, and the case moves to superior court. North Dakota's court page says there is no jury and that the decision cannot be appealed. Those are choices the state has made. They are not universal.

The usual subjects are unpaid bills, damaged property, security deposits, bad checks, and work that was paid for and not finished. Connecticut's judicial FAQ lists contract claims and medical bills as examples that can belong, and it points reputation claims elsewhere. Arizona's statute excludes evictions, defamation, class actions, and claims against the state. Hawaii's judiciary guide allows a residential security-deposit dispute and, in that kind of case only, forbids lawyers for both sides. Read the exclusion list for the court you will actually use. A dispute can be "small" in dollars and still be the wrong kind of case.

Filing is local. You use the clerk of the court that has jurisdiction over the person you are suing or over the place where the dispute happened. The forms are the court's forms. Staff can tell you the fee and the service method. They generally cannot tell you what to write or whether your evidence is enough. Alabama's court guide says that limit in so many words.

A judgment is a decision that someone owes money. It is not the money itself. Collection is a later step, with its own forms. If you need the court to order someone to do something other than pay, many of these courts cannot help. Utah's courts page says you cannot ask for an order that someone give property back. Vermont's judiciary guide says the same thing about orders to act. Texas's State Law Library says a small-claims judge awards financial compensation.

Before you file, match three things: the court your state actually uses, the dollar line on that court's current page or statute, and the kind of relief the statute allows. Then decide whether the simplified hearing is the hearing you want. In Rhode Island, choosing the small-claims procedure means the plaintiff waives an appeal. In North Dakota, the court page says the decision is final. In other states an appeal exists and may be a new trial, as Maryland and Delaware describe for their smaller civil dockets. The pamphlet is the start. The statute and the clerk's instructions are the rest.

Sources

Free checklist

Before You File

Questions to answer from the official court page before you file a small claim.

Free. We email you the download link, plus an occasional plain-English guide. Unsubscribe any time. We never sell your email. Privacy